The Top 5 SEO Mistakes That Every Business Should Avoid

Robert Fuller

Organic traffic typically makes up 60 - 70% of a sites traffic and tends to be the highest converting form of traffic. Here's the top 5 SEO mistakes to avoid hurting your business's Search Engine Rankings or losing your organic traffic.

First of all, we want to commend you for actually thinking about Search Engine Optimization (SEO). It’s not sexy, or fun (unless you’re nerds like us). It’s not easy to understand, there’s math and research and…ok, we see your eyes glaze over. But SEO tweaks work. They work to generate more traffic to your website and therefore, more revenue. 


A research firm called Sistrix recently did a study of billions of Google search results. They found that 28.5% of people searching for a term on Google click on the very first organic result. The 10th result on the page had only a 2.5% click rate.

The importance of this study cannot be overstated. It means that a potential customer or client is 10 times more likely to buy from a company that is on the first page of Google than they are to research customer reviews. There seems to be an assumption that the first option is the best option, and very few people have the time to do a deep dive into consumer reports. 


So, let’s get to it the meaty bits here: SEO is a powerful tool that can be used incorrectly. It can throw people off track, confuse people, and invite the wrong kind of business or client into your life. We’ll unpack this now.

Mistake #1: Stuffing your Meta Keywords


Meta descriptions appear below your listing in a Search Engine and are best used to encourage clicks. This means, write them for the people searching, not for search engines. Gone are the days of term - term - term - term….this is boring for people, and not eye-catching.


For example, consider the difference between these two meta descriptions for a fancy sock company:


Description 1:
Socks - fancy - warm - socks - family - unique - colorful - playful - whacky - dress - formal - cottage - socks- vacation - boardroom - business


Description 2:
Fancy socks to dress up your business attire, or warmer options for your cottage or vacation. Make a statement or give a unique gift to someone special!

The first description can actually get you penalized by Google algorithms: it uses the keyword three times in the meta description. Just give an overview, use enticing descriptive copy, and write for the customer, not a robot!


Mistake #2: Using Content Exclusively Generated By AI


Artificially created website content (there are various AI copy generating apps online) are not inherently negative. In truth, they are also improving all the time. BUT: AI text generators rely on statistical patterns. While some content follows predictable structures, such as FAQ chat posts and simple report inquiries, AI has not developed to the extent that it can discern natural language. You need a human writer to convey the actual meaning of words and sentences. Oh, and add a little personality here and there for readability!

Free website needs assessment the best websites have conversion rates of 11% or more does yours ?

Publish engaging, thought-leadership style articles and people can tell the difference. Be authentic and invest your time in writing good content! If you’re not a writer, find one of the many websites online such as Upwork or Elance which offer writing and copy-editing services.


Mistake #3: Duplicating Content On Your Site


Repeating the exact same content over and over again on your site confuses your users as well as search engines. If a search engine can’t decide which content is the original,
all of it will take a hit in the rankings.


More importantly, your conversion rates will crash. Your users don’t want to read the same thing over and over again on your site. User experience will suffer greatly, and people will click away from your web pages out of sheer boredom and frustration.


Google sees the duplication of site content as a lack of effort, and in some cases, as plagiarism. Make it a point to write new content and to write it well!

Mistake #4: Buying Backlinks


Buying backlinks, for those who don’t know, is the all-too common practice of paying to have your website link appear on another website: usually a directory or coupon site, etc. 


There are 3 main reasons not to buy backlinks:


One: You’re almost definitely wasting money.
Buying clicks from sites like directories or forums will have little to no real impact on your rankings. Google is able to identify quality links from links that come from sites without any real traffic. Plus if you're buying links a lot of times you're dealing with spamier sites that actually hurt your rankings.


Two: Link purchasing is directly against Google Webmaster Guidelines
. In fact, buying backlinks can result in the dreaded Manual Penalty. In fact Google placed even more emphasis on weeding out what they consider spammy backlink profiles on sites with their core algorithm updates at the beginning of 2022. This can cause dramatic drops in your search rankings or even your site being completely removed from Google!

An advertisement for proshark with a map on top of a keyboard

Mistake #5: Using misleading or sensationalized headlines! 


Facebook and Google both identify phrases commonly used in clickbait style headlines, such as FREE, or WIN, etc. Links posted from sites or pages that consistently use clickbait headlines appear lower in the newsfeed and search listings. 


Even worse, this type of headline diminishes trust with your audience. People are getting used to this type of approach and it is resulting in lower traffic totals. The assumption is that nothing is really free, they will wind up getting spammed if they provide their email just to enter a draw, and the overall experience they have with your brand will be hella negative.


Clickbait headlines also tend to result in higher bounce rates and a poor user experience which hurts your overall brand image.


The SEO Takeaway:


Good marketing is only a mystery if you do NOT think about your potential customers as if they were actual, intelligent, busy people. You can’t capture attention and interest with sales copy anymore. You need to build a solid audience by providing high quality content. Who are the people you are selling to? Are you helping them with a problem? How are you helping them? What is your area of expertise? Tweaking your SEO is important, but only when you have a grounded, compassionate way of communicating respectfully to your expanding audience. Niche down, solve a problem, and do it with grace and style.


And then test and tweak away until you have mastered the art of Search Engine Optimization!

A button that says `` schedule an appointment '' on a white background.

If you want guidance on your SEO strategy or any other of your digital marketing needs Proshark is a full-stack digital marketing agency and software development company.

We are your premier one-stop agency for all of your marketing needs.


Our goal is simple – drive results for our clients our clients.


We deliver the knowledge and skills needed to grow your business and results that help your business thrive!


At Proshark, we know you have a choice and we want that choice to be us. We consider ourselves partners in your business and look forward to making it a journey filled with success.

February 19, 2025
The Battle Between Performance and Branding In the fast-paced world of digital marketing, two key strategies dominate conversations—performance marketing and branding. Both are essential for business growth, yet they serve distinct purposes. Performance marketing is all about immediate results, measurable returns, and data-driven strategies, while branding focuses on long-term perception, trust, and loyalty. But here’s the challenge: How do businesses strike the right balance between the two? Can companies drive revenue while building an emotional connection with their audience? In this blog, we’ll explore the strengths, weaknesses, and best practices for integrating performance marketing and branding into a unified strategy.
February 18, 2025
Most businesses focus on customer acquisition —getting more leads, running paid ads, and optimizing their sales funnels. But here’s the harsh reality : Acquiring a new customer can cost five times more than retaining an existing one. Yet, many brands still prioritize conversion over retention. Retention marketing is the secret weapon that 10x’s revenue, increases lifetime value (LTV), and builds sustainable growth. If you’re constantly chasing new customers but ignoring the ones you already have, you’re leaving money on the table.
February 17, 2025
Marketing technology (MarTech) has revolutionized how businesses reach, engage, and convert customers. In today’s fast-paced digital world, having the right MarTech stack isn’t just an advantage—it’s a necessity. Whether you're a small business looking to automate processes or a large enterprise aiming for data-driven decision-making, MarTech tools can streamline operations, enhance personalization, and improve ROI.  But with thousands of MarTech solutions available, how do you choose the right ones? This guide explores the must-have MarTech tools for scaling your digital strategy, categorized by their specific functions in the marketing ecosystem.
More Posts
Share by: